Current:Home > FinanceRobert Brown|What went wrong at Silicon Valley Bank? The Fed is set to release a postmortem report -ProfitSphere Academy
Robert Brown|What went wrong at Silicon Valley Bank? The Fed is set to release a postmortem report
Poinbank View
Date:2025-04-10 07:59:19
It's been six weeks since the collapse of Silicon Valley Bank and Robert BrownSignature Bank threatened to kick off a nationwide bank run. Now, U.S. regulators are due to issue their postmortem reports.
The Federal Reserve plans to release a report Friday on whether there were lapses in its oversight of Silicon Valley Bank that may have contributed to the bank's failure.
Separately, the Federal Deposit Insurance Corp. will also report Friday on how the regulator supervised New York-based Signature Bank, which failed days after the Silicon Valley lender.
The sudden implosion of two big regional banks rattled nerves throughout the financial system last month, forcing the federal government to take emergency steps to prevent a nationwide bank run.
Here are a few things to watch ahead of those two reports.
What did the Fed know – and when did it know it?
It was a "textbook case of mismanagement."
That was how Michael Barr, the Fed's vice chair for supervision, described the failure of Silicon Valley Bank during Senate testimony last month.
But the Fed has also promised to examine whether gaps in its own oversight allowed problems at the bank to fester.
Supervisors from the Federal Reserve had sounded warnings about risk management practices at Silicon Valley Bank as early as 2021, but the problems weren't corrected.
It's not clear why the warnings weren't treated more urgently by bank management – or higher-ups at the Fed.
"We need to have humility, and conduct a careful and thorough review of how we supervised and regulated this firm, and what we should learn from this experience," said Barr, in announcing the Fed's internal audit of what happened at Silicon Valley Bank.
Dennis Kelleher, who heads the watchdog group Better Markets, blames a deregulatory push in recent years that promoted a light touch on bank oversight.
"The Wall Street Journal had a big headline in 2018 that said, 'Banks To Get Kinder, Gentler Treatment Under Trump Regulators,'" Kelleher said. "The entire story was about how the Fed people in Washington were beating up on the supervisors to go easy on the bankers."
The report is also expected to address whether mid-sized banks should be subject to more frequent "stress tests," to ensure they can weather financial challenges.
Currently, only the biggest banks — with at least $250 billion in assets — have to undergo a stress test every year. That threshold was raised in 2019, sparing institutions the size of Silicon Valley Bank from the additional scrutiny.
Whose deposits are protected?
Signature Bank in New York was shuttered two days after Silicon Valley Bank. The FDIC is due to examine whether there were any issues with how it supervised the East Coast lender.
Both banks had a large share of deposits that exceeded the usual FDIC insurance limit of $250,000 — putting them at high risk of rapid withdrawals if customers got spooked.
With emergency approval from the Treasury Secretary and the Fed, the FDIC agreed to insure all deposits at the two failed banks, regardless of the limit. That helped to discourage a wider bank run, but backstopping the uninsured deposits will cost the FDIC's insurance fund an estimated $19.6 billion. The money will be recovered through a special assessment on other banks.
Now, policymakers may explore changes in the deposit insurance system. Some have argued the $250,000 cap on insured deposits is too low, especially for businesses with large payrolls. But insuring unlimited deposits would be costly. The ten largest accounts at Silicon Valley Bank held a total of $13.3 billion.
Changing the insurance limit would require Congressional action. The FDIC is expected to spell out policy options in a separate report next week.
What about beyond these two reports?
Fears of a nationwide bank run have eased since last month, but the episode has left lingering scars.
In the days following the banks' failure, other small banks saw a record outflow of deposits totaling $119 billion. Although deposits have since stabilized at most banks, lenders are expected to be more cautious about extending credit.
That caution, along with higher interest rates, creates an additional drag on economic growth, and it's leading to a growing risk of a recession later this year.
"Every borrower across the country — small, medium and large — is going to find it much more difficult and much more expensive to get credit," said Ian Shepherdson, chief economist at Pantheon Macroeconomics. "The economy's going to be materially weaker than it likely would have been without the SVB and Signature failures."
veryGood! (6443)
Related
- Grammy nominee Teddy Swims on love, growth and embracing change
- Lost Death Valley visitors trek across salt flat after car gets stuck: It could have cost their lives
- Drag artists and LGBTQ+ activities sue to block Texas law expanding ban on sexual performances
- Woman escapes kidnapper's cell in Oregon; FBI searching for more victims in other states
- Toyota to invest $922 million to build a new paint facility at its Kentucky complex
- Who is Jack Smith, the special counsel overseeing the DOJ's Trump probes?
- Surfs up takes on new meaning as California waves get bigger as Earth warms, research finds
- This Northern Manhattan Wetland Has Faced Climate-Change-Induced Erosion and Sea Level Rise. A Living Shoreline Has Reimagined the Space
- Are Instagram, Facebook and WhatsApp down? Meta says most issues resolved after outages
- 'A violation of our sovereignty': 2 bodies found in Rio Grande, one near a floating barrier
Ranking
- The FTC says 'gamified' online job scams by WhatsApp and text on the rise. What to know.
- 2 members of expelled ‘Tennessee Three’ vie to win back their legislative seats
- 2 members of expelled ‘Tennessee Three’ vie to win back their legislative seats
- Kate Chastain Says This Made Her Consider Returning to Below Deck
- Mets have visions of grandeur, and a dynasty, with Juan Soto as major catalyst
- Montrezl Harrell, 76ers big man and former NBA Sixth Man of the Year, has torn ACL
- Hurry, the Ulta Sale Ends Tonight: Save Up to 50% On Olaplex, Philosophy, MAC, and More
- ACLU files lawsuit against drag show restrictions in Texas
Recommendation
IRS recovers $4.7 billion in back taxes and braces for cuts with Trump and GOP in power
Truck full of nacho cheese leaves sticky mess on Arkansas highway
Ex-NFL cornerback Damon Arnette must appear in court for plea deal in felony gun case, judge says
Who is Jack Smith, the special counsel overseeing the DOJ's Trump probes?
Meet first time Grammy nominee Charley Crockett
Gunman shot on community college campus in San Diego after killing police dog, authorities say
Exclusive: First look at 2024 PGA Tour schedule; 4 designated events to keep 36-hole cut
How much money do you need to retire? Americans have a magic number — and it's big.